Full Topic Map

Views: List of Points Pros and Cons Slideshow

Tools:  Essay Planner Presentation PlannerPrintable Version

  • because: helps protect the environment
    • because: changes attitude and behavior of the community
      • because: deters people from plastic bag consumption
        • because: success in Ireland
      • because: succcess of no-plastic bag days
      • because: people will use recycled bags instead
        • because: It can protect the environment since the amount of...
        • because: expects to cut the use from 1.8b to 1b annually
    • because: public awareness of environment protection
    • but: retailers will switch to other polluting options
    • but: not urgent to the environment
      • but: 33m plastic bags are disposed in landfills per day
      • because: govn't should develop recycling industry
        • because: recycling plastic bag is cost-effective
      • because: manufacturing plastic bags is energy-efficient
        • because: embodied energy can be recovered
      • because: polystyrene causes more problems
  • because: increases government revenue
    • but: revenue raised is spent on environmental projects
      • because: not intend to raise money for govn't
    • because: govn't expects to generate HK$200m/yr
    • because: success in Ireland
    • because: broadens tax base
Implementing a plastic bag tax would be beneficial for Hong Kong
  • but: affects people living
    • but: many goods will be exempted
    • because: affects the business of small supermarkets
    • because: plastic bags are useful
  • but: the tax is unfair
    • but: fair: "user pays" principle
    • because: regressive in nature
      • but: all people can avoid tax by not using plastic bags
  • because: beneficial to the economy
    • but: affects plastic bag manufacturing industry
    • because: improves image, attracts talent
    • because: good for environmental protection business