1. Content
Does all your writing refer to the topic of your seminar?
Have you included the main points you discussed in the seminar, and any other relevant
points?
2. Organisation, coherence and cohesion
a. Organisation
- Have you got an introduction and a conclusion?
- Have you put each main point in a separate paragraph?
- Have you got an empty line between each paragraph?
Book in CILL: Hefferman, J & Lincoln, J (1996) Writing: a concise handbook
New York, Norton pp12-20 (Writing Shelf, Intermediate Level)
b. Coherence
- Does each paragraph have a topic sentence containing the main idea of the paragraph and
your opinion about it?
- Does each paragraph explain why you believe the opinion that you have written in the
topic sentence?
Book in CILL: Reid, J. (1998) The Process of Composition New Jersey, Prentice
Hall, p.69-70 (Study Skills Shelf, Upper-intermediate Level)
c. Cohesion
- Do you use logical connecting words such as and, but,
however, so, and therefore? (Dont use
moreover.)
Book in CILL: Potter, J. (1994) Common Business English Errors in Hong Kong Hong
Kong, Longman, Chapter 11 (Grammar Shelf, Intermediate Level)
- Do you use a to write about a countable subject for the first time, and
the to write about the same subject later?
Book in CILL: Potter, J. (1994) Common Business English Errors in Hong Kong Hong
Kong, Longman, page 38 (Grammar Shelf, Intermediate Level)
- Do you use It, They, This and These to
refer back to a subject in the previous sentence or paragraph?
3. Register
- Is your writing formal?
e.g. write did not instead of didnt, and a great
deal of instead of a lot of.
- Is your writing polite?
e.g. Dont write, It is foolish to believe that
. Use, It is
questionable whether
.
4. Accuracy of Grammar and Vocabulary
- Does each sentence have a subject and a verb?
Book in CILL: Hefferman, J & Lincoln, J (1996) Writing: a concise handbook
New York, Norton pp59 - 73 (Writing Shelf, Intermediate Level)
- Have you checked each noun to see if it is countable, uncountable, or abstract, and used
the correct article ( a / an / the / no article) ?
Book in CILL: Potter, J. (1994) Common Business English Errors in Hong Kong Hong
Kong, Longman, Chapters 3 & 4 (Grammar Shelf, Intermediate Level)
- Have you checked the noun before each verb to see if it is third person (he, she, or it)
and changed the end of the verb to +s for present tense regular verbs; e.g.
Hong Kong changes quickly. ?
- Do you use the present simple tense to describe things you think are true all the time;
e.g. Hong Kong is an international city. ?
Book in CILL: Potter, J. (1994) Common Business English Errors in Hong Kong Hong
Kong, Longman, Chapter 5 (Grammar Shelf, Intermediate Level)
- Do you use the present perfect tense to describe experience or the results of
experience; e.g. I have been a university student for 2 months and I have become a
more independent learner. ?
.
- Do you use the simple past tense to describe things that finished in the past; e.g.
Hong Kong was a British colony until 1997. ?
5. Range of Grammar and Vocabulary
If there are things that you dont know how to say in English, have you checked
how to say them in a dictionary, or with your EAP teacher or a CILL teacher?
6. Academic-style writing (see Unit 6 of the blue EAP book)
- Is your conclusion based on evidence and facts?
- Have you defined terms and words that your teacher might not know?
- If you have described something as good or better than
,
have you given reasons why?
- Have you avoided asking questions, then answering them?
- Have you used academic-style writing to show how sure you are of your information
(see pages 111-2 of the blue EAP book)?
- Have you replaced phrasal verbs such as look at with more formal words such
as examine?
- Have you avoided using you to refer to your reader; e.g. You must
agree that
?
- Have you avoided over-generalisations; e.g. Everyone knows
that
?
7. Number of Words
a. Is your writing 400 500 words long?
b. Is your text double-spaced (i.e. one empty line between each line of writing) ?
|
Yes/No |