- because: morally acceptable
- because: criteria: moral acceptability
- because: promotes men's best interests
- but: it's a harmful act
- but: not the best interest
- because: vulnerability of human beings
- because: alturistic decisions
- because: under pressure
- because: shortage of resources
- because: merely a passing phase
- because: panic sufferers
- because: confused patients
- because: mistaken diagnosis
- because: inappropriate medications
- because: doctor's carelessness
- because: depressing world view
- because: fallability of men's interests
- but: interests may be immoral
- because: the right to end life
- but: It is illegal because someone may make use...
- but: social responsibility of dying
- because: a communitarian issue
- because: it's a public act
- because: weakens respect for live
- because: less good care for the ills
- because: cost-effective means
- because: it's a cheaper plan
- because: euthanasia is cheaper
- because: high cost of medication
- because: undermines doctors' commitment
- because: discourages good care
- because: discourages further researchs
- because: social problems entailed
- because: negative effect on vulnerables
- because: patients abandoned by family
- because: pressure on the elders
- because: rights & obligations
- but: only God has such right
- because: One has no obligation in bearing continuous...
- because: autonomy should be respected
- but: lack of evidence for autonomy
- because: cases of unconscious patients
- but: instructions can be given in advance
- but: seems unlikely to be rational
- but: paternalistic
- because: sufficient evidences exist
- but: not a valid objection
- but: not the whole picture
- because: It is a kind of mental torture for a person...
- because: control over life
- because: freedom should be maximized
|
- but: difficulty of legislation
- but: vulnerables better protected
- because: formal procedure as protection
- but: better than no law
- because: euthanasia takes place anyway
- but: unreasonable objection
- because: analogy of murdering
- because: slippery slope for abuse
- but: more dangerous if no law
- because: no transparency without law
- because: voluntariness unassured
Voluntary euthanasia should be legalized
- but: no reason to give life up
- but: Death is not a bad thing
- but: death violates autonomy
- because: life implies death
- because: dead=nonexistent
- but: death hurts people
- but: if the new life is not welcomed and cared, being b
- because: death terminates
- because: nothing bad about nonexistent
- because: life is intrinsically valuable
|
- but: giving doctors too much power
- but: acceptable if well regulated
- but: patients in fact make decision
- but: lives are equal
- but: Proper palliative care
- but: not adequate
- because: not wildly accessible
- but: We must take care of everyone in the...
- because: side effects
- because: not a universal preference
- because: not wanting to die in distress
- because: mental suffering matters more
- because: fear about the result of care
- because: some want to die consciously
- because: some want to die at home
- because: dependency
- because: pain not properly relieved
- because: palliative care maybe useful
- because: Pros and cons to palliative care
- but: Suffering may have value
- but: You have given no explanation to this to...
- but: it's not the doctors' right
- but: it's normal
- but: extend life=control death
- but: it's doctors' job nature
- because: criteria: legal acceptability
- because: voluntary euthanasia should be legalized...
- because: fair distribution of resources
- but: liability to be abused
- because: creates false patients' images
- but: this will lead to the abuse
- but: moral, not economic issue
- because: better use of resources
|